For over three years, the typical American property consistently sold for a higher price than it did the previous year, month after month. However, that trend has come to an end. National data from October indicates that the median sale price for homes has dipped slightly below last year's figures, marking the first annual decrease since spring 2023. Concurrently, the number of homes available on the market has risen to its highest point since early 2020, pending sales have dropped to their lowest levels in over a decade (excluding the initial pandemic period), and nearly 20% of listings have experienced a price reduction.
The flip side is that borrowing costs have once again increased. As of the past week, the average rate for a 30-year fixed mortgage has surged back into the mid-7% range, following a short period of improvement. This means that although buyers now have more negotiating power, for many households, monthly payments remain a significant challenge.
This unique situation creates an interesting dynamic for the real estate market. With fewer offers being made and properties remaining on the market longer, sellers are becoming more open to discussions. This change in attitude can affect both the price and the overall terms of the sale. If you are in search of a home this winter, here are several aspects that could be up for negotiation and considerations to discuss with your agent and lender.
A national price decline of less than half a percent does not indicate a market crash and doesn't imply that prices are dropping uniformly. Certain high-value coastal areas with limited inventory continue to see price increases, while various large metropolitan areas in the South and West have recorded declines of a few percentage points compared to the previous year. It is essential to focus on your local market as it plays a more significant role than the national figures.
What those national statistics highlight is a shift in market power. With homes taking longer to sell and more listings vying for fewer buyers, sellers tend to become more amenable to negotiations. This openness can reflect not only in the final sale price but also in various terms associated with the transaction.
While many buyers place their entire focus on the purchase price, in a high-interest-rate climate, the overall monthly payment and the amount needed at closing can be even more critical. A discount of a few thousand dollars on the purchase price results in only a slight reduction in your loan amount. Conversely, reallocating that same sum differently can yield greater advantages for your financial situation. In slower markets, common negotiation points include:
Your agent possesses valuable insights regarding how sellers in your area are responding and can assist you in determining which of these options to incorporate into your offer. The aim should not be to request everything you can think of but to select the elements that will have the most significant impact on your purchase.
Closing costs typically represent a few percent of the total loan amount on top of your down payment. For many first-time buyers, gathering the necessary funds can present the greatest challenge when purchasing a home. A seller credit can help cover some of these expenses, allowing you to bring less cash to closing.
There are some limitations to be aware of. Various loan programs stipulate caps on how much a seller can contribute, often ranging from 3% to 9% of the purchase price depending on loan type and down payment size. Generally, these credits cannot exceed your actual closing costs. Therefore, it's advisable to consult your lender early on to understand what your specific loan allows so that your offer aligns with the established guidelines.
With interest rates now exceeding 7%, a seller's assistance with lowering your interest rate could prove highly beneficial. There are primarily two types of buydowns.
A permanent buydown involves purchasing discount points at closing to reduce your interest rate for the entire duration of the loan. Each point typically costs 1% of the loan amount, and the extent of the rate decrease varies depending on the lender and current market conditions. If you intend to retain the loan for several years, a permanent buydown could be financially advantageous.
A temporary buydown reduces your payments for the initial year or two. In a frequently used scenario, the interest rate is lowered by two percentage points in the first year and by one percentage point in the second year, before reverting to the full rate. For instance, on a $350,000 loan at approximately 7.34%, the monthly payments would be around $2,409. With a temporary buydown of this nature, the payment in the first year would drop to about $1,952 and rise to approximately $2,176 in the second year before returning to the standard payment in the third year. Implementing this structure could cost just over $8,000 in the aforementioned example, which a seller might be willing to cover instead of reducing the price by a similar amount.
Though a temporary buydown presents immediate relief, it is not a long-term solution. Buyers must ensure they're comfortable with the full payment once the introductory rate ends. Moreover, lenders usually base their qualification on the standard interest rate. If rates decrease in the future, refinancing may become a possibility, yet no one can predict precisely when or if that will occur.
During the preceding competitive markets, many buyers opted to waive inspections or limit requests to secure an advantage in bidding wars. However, as the market slows, there is less necessity to forego those critical protections. Conducting a thorough home inspection helps provide insights into the state of the roof, HVAC systems, plumbing, electrical systems, and foundation before committing to the purchase.
If the inspection reveals any issues, your agent can guide you on whether to ask for repairs, a price adjustment, or a credit. Credits can at times be simpler than dealing with seller-managed repairs, as they grant you the autonomy to control who performs the work and how it's executed; however, determining the right option depends on the nature of the problem and the stipulations of your loan.
Having strong negotiating power is futile if your financing situation is not secure. Sellers will usually lean towards the buyer whose offer appears more likely to successfully close. Prior to starting your property search, obtain a full preapproval rather than a quick prequalification, understand your comfortable monthly payment limits rather than just the maximum loan amount, and evaluate loan estimates from multiple lenders. Inquire with each lender about how they handle seller credits or buydowns to avoid surprises down the line.
A more relaxed market does not necessarily translate to finding inexpensive options, particularly given the ongoing rise in mortgage rates. However, it does afford well-prepared buyers greater latitude to negotiate favorable terms that suit their financial circumstances. With solid financing, a clear understanding of your priorities, and support from your agent and lender, you may be able to secure terms that surpass expectations from even a year or two past.
Rewritten using AI
Whether you're acquiring, repositioning, or exchanging assets, our advisors deliver strategic insight, responsive communication, and proven results at every stage.